別人問 Would you mind,你回 Yes 就糟了!

Would you mind 怎麼回答?回 Yes 就糟了 | MJ英語 Daily English | 生活英語

飛機上,隔壁乘客客氣地問你 “Would you mind closing the window shade?” 你熱心回 “Yes, of course!”,對方卻一臉猶豫——因為你剛剛說的其實是「對,我介意」。

被問 Would you mind…? 想答應要說 No, not at all. 或 Not at all.;自己拜託別人用 Would you mind + V-ing:Would you mind letting me out?

💡 先搞懂:mind=介意,所以要回 No 才是「好啊」

Would you mind…? 字面意思是「你介意…嗎?」。中文習慣先說「好啊」,但這題的「好」其實是「不介意」,所以要回 No, not at all. 或 Not at all.。回 Yes 等於說「對,我介意」,對方可能會以為你不願意。口語裡也常聽到母語者直接回 Sure.,但最不會被誤會的是 Not at all.。另外,自己用 Would you mind 拜託別人時,後面要接 V-ing,不是 to。

台灣人最容易卡的雷:① 被問 Would you mind…? 回 Yes, of course! → No, not at all.;② Would you mind to let me out? → Would you mind letting me out?;③ Would you mind I sit here? → Would you mind if I sit here?


情境對話 Dialogue

邊聽邊學

這一集完整音檔就在這裡,也可以到 Apple 或 Spotify 收聽

立即播放約 8 分

場景:白天的長途班機上,陽光從窗戶直射進來。Eric 坐靠窗,旁邊靠走道的是美國女生 Rachel。


Rachel

Excuse me, would you mind closing the window shade? The sun is right in my eyes.

不好意思,可以麻煩你把遮光板拉下來嗎?太陽直接照到我眼睛。

Eric

Yes, of course!

好啊,當然!(但回 Yes 的意思其實是「對,我介意」)

Rachel

Oh. So you do mind? That’s okay, I can just move.

喔……所以你介意?沒關係,那我換個位置就好。

Eric

No, no! I mean, I’m happy to close it.

不不不!我是說,我很樂意拉下來。

Rachel

Ha, got it. With would you mind, you say, no, not at all. No means it’s fine.

哈,懂了。被問 would you mind,要回 no, not at all。說 no 才是沒問題。

Eric

Oh! So yes means I mind. Okay then, not at all.

喔!所以 yes 是我介意。好,那就 not at all。

Rachel

Thank you. That’s so much better.

謝謝,這樣好多了。

Eric

Can I ask you something too? Would you mind to let me out? I need the restroom.

我也可以拜託你一件事嗎?可以讓我出去一下嗎?我要去洗手間。(mind 後面接了 to)

Rachel

Not at all. Little tip: would you mind letting me out. No to, just the ing form.

不介意,請便。給你一個小提醒:would you mind letting me out,不加 to,用 ing 就好。

Eric

Would you mind letting me out. Got it! Thanks for the free English lesson.

Would you mind letting me out,懂了!謝謝你免費的英文課。

🎯 30 秒快速複習

mind=介意。被問 Would you mind…? 答應:No, not at all./婉拒:Sorry, I’d rather not./自己拜託:Would you mind + V-ing?/問我可以嗎:Would you mind if I…?/禮貌三層:Can you → Could you → Would you mind

①可以麻煩你…嗎=Would you mind + V-ing?
②好啊,不介意=No, not at all.
③沒問題=Not at all. / No problem.
④不太方便=Sorry, I’d rather not.
⑤我可以…嗎=Would you mind if I…?
⑥請便=Go ahead.
⑦朋友之間=Can you…?
⑧客氣一點=Could you…?

下次這樣說 Next Time

Would you mind 這三種用法最容易講錯。

① 被問 Would you mind

❌ 中文腦會說

Yes, of course!

等於「我介意」

✅ 該這樣說

No, not at all.

不介意=好啊

為什麼:mind 是「介意」,Would you mind…? 是「你介意…嗎?」,回 Yes 就變成「我介意」。口語也常聽到 Sure.,但 Not at all. 最不會被誤會。

② 自己拜託別人

❌ 中文腦會說

Would you mind to let me out?

mind 不接 to

✅ 該這樣說

Would you mind letting me out?

mind+V-ing

為什麼:mind 後面要接 V-ing:Would you mind closing…? Would you mind helping…? 不說 mind to。

③ 問「我可以…嗎」

❌ 中文腦會說

Would you mind I sit here?

少了 if

✅ 該這樣說

Would you mind if I sit here?

加 if

為什麼:問自己能不能做某件事,要用 Would you mind if I…? 或 Do you mind if I…?,對方回 Go ahead. 或 Not at all. 就是可以。


重點單字 Vocabulary Boost

mind/maɪnd/ v.

介意。

Would you mind closing the window shade?(可以麻煩你拉下遮光板嗎?)

not at all/nɑːt ət ɔːl/

一點也不(回答 Would you mind 時=好啊,不介意)。

Not at all. Go ahead.(不介意,請便。)

window shade/ˈwɪndoʊ ʃeɪd/ n.

(飛機的)遮光板。

Would you mind closing the window shade?(可以拉下遮光板嗎?)

window seat/ˈwɪndoʊ siːt/ n.

靠窗的座位。

Eric has the window seat.(Eric 坐靠窗的位子。)

go ahead/ɡoʊ əˈhed/

請便、請說。

Go ahead.(請便。)

would rather/wʊd ˈræðər/

寧願(I’d rather not=我不太想、不太方便)。

Sorry, I’d rather not.(抱歉,不太方便。)

aisle seat/aɪl siːt/ n.

靠走道的座位。

She has the aisle seat.(她坐靠走道的位子。)

restroom/ˈrestruːm/ n.

洗手間。

I need the restroom.(我要去洗手間。)


重點句型 Sentence Patterns

1. 更客氣的拜託 → Would you mind + V-ing?

mind 後面接 V-ing,不接 to。

例:Would you mind closing the window shade?(可以麻煩你拉下遮光板嗎?)
例:Would you mind letting me out?(可以讓我出去一下嗎?)
例:Would you mind speaking a little slower?(可以麻煩你講慢一點嗎?)
想對陌生人、長輩、客戶客氣拜託事情,可以用這句。

2. 答應別人 → No, not at all.

不介意=好啊,所以要回 No。

例:No, not at all.(不會,一點也不介意。)
例:Not at all. Go ahead.(不介意,請便。)
例:No problem.(沒問題。)
很多母語者也會直接回 Sure.,但 Not at all. 最不會被誤會。

3. 婉拒 → Sorry, I’d rather not.

想拒絕也別直接說 Yes, I mind,太衝。

例:Sorry, I’d rather not.(抱歉,我不太想。)
例:Sorry, I can’t right now.(抱歉,現在沒辦法。)
例:I’m afraid I can’t.(恐怕沒辦法。)
先說 Sorry 再拒絕,語氣就柔和很多。

4. 問「我可以…嗎」→ Would you mind if I…?

問自己能不能做某件事,要加 if。

例:Would you mind if I sit here?(我可以坐這裡嗎?)
例:Do you mind if I open the window?(我開個窗可以嗎?)
例:Mind if I join you?(我可以加入嗎?)
對方回 Go ahead. 或 Not at all. 就是可以。

5. 禮貌三層 → Can you → Could you → Would you mind

越往後越客氣。

例:Can you pass the salt?(朋友之間)
例:Could you pass the salt?(客氣一點)
例:Would you mind passing the salt?(更客氣)
對陌生人或長輩,從 Could you 開始用就不會錯。

逐字稿 Transcript

J
Okay, small confession. A coworker once asked me, “Would you mind helping me with this?” and I said, “Yes, of course!” She just stared at me. I’m Jason, by the way. I thought I was being friendly. I was actually saying no.小小告白一下。有次同事問我:「Would you mind helping me with this?」我回:「Yes, of course!」她就瞪著我看。對了,我是 Jason。我以為自己很親切,其實我是在說不要。
M
And I’m Mary. Oh, that happens so much! Here’s why. “Mind” means “to be bothered by.” So “Would you mind?” really asks, “Does it bother you?” Today we’ll fix this with a little story from a long flight.我是 Mary。這種事超常發生!原因是這樣:mind 的意思是「覺得困擾、介意」。所以「Would you mind?」其實是在問「這會讓你困擾嗎?」今天我們用一個長途飛行的小故事來把它搞懂。
J
Picture it. It’s a long daytime flight. Eric, a guy from Taiwan, has the window seat. Rachel, an American woman, sits next to him in the aisle seat. And the sun is shining straight through the window.想像一下。這是一趟白天的長途班機。來自台灣的 Eric 坐靠窗的位子,美國女生 Rachel 坐在他旁邊的走道位。陽光正直直從窗戶照進來。
M
And Rachel says, “Excuse me, would you mind closing the window shade? The sun is right in my eyes.” Very polite. Eric wants to help, so he answers super fast. He says, “Yes, of course!”然後 Rachel 說:「Excuse me, would you mind closing the window shade? The sun is right in my eyes.」很有禮貌。Eric 想幫忙,所以他馬上回答:「Yes, of course!」
J
But remember, she asked, “Do you mind?” So “Yes” means “Yes, I mind.” That’s what Rachel hears. She hesitates and says, “Oh. So you do mind? That’s okay, I can just move.” Poor Eric!但別忘了,她問的是「你介意嗎?」所以 Yes 就是「對,我介意」。Rachel 聽到的就是這個意思。她猶豫了一下說:「Oh. So you do mind? That’s okay, I can just move.」可憐的 Eric!
M
Eric panics a little. He says, “No, no! I mean, I’m happy to close it.” Rachel laughs and explains, “With would you mind, you say, no, not at all. No means it’s fine.” I love that tip.Eric 有點慌。他說:「No, no! I mean, I’m happy to close it.」Rachel 笑著解釋:「With would you mind, you say, no, not at all. No means it’s fine.」我超愛這個小提醒。
J
That’s the key, right? For “Would you mind?” the happy answer is no. So you say, “No, not at all.” Or just, “Not at all.” Or, “No problem.” All three mean, “Sure, I’m totally fine with it.”這就是關鍵,對吧?被問「Would you mind?」,開心的答案是 no。所以你說:「No, not at all.」或只說「Not at all.」,或「No problem.」這三句都是「當然,我完全沒問題」。
M
Eric gets it fast. He says, “Oh! So yes means I mind. Okay then, not at all.” And Rachel says, “Thank you. That’s so much better.” The sun is gone, and everybody’s happy.Eric 很快就懂了。他說:「Oh! So yes means I mind. Okay then, not at all.」Rachel 說:「Thank you. That’s so much better.」陽光不見了,大家都開心。
J
Now, an honest note. Native speakers often just say “Sure,” too, and that’s totally fine. But “Not at all” is the safest one, because nobody can misunderstand it. If you feel nervous, pick that one.老實說一下。母語人士也常常直接回「Sure.」,這完全沒問題。但「Not at all」是最保險的,因為不會有人誤會。如果你會緊張,就選這句。
M
What if you really don’t want to do it? Don’t say, “Yes, I mind.” That sounds too blunt. Try, “Sorry, I’d rather not.” Or, “Sorry, I can’t right now.” Starting with “Sorry” makes it so much softer.如果你真的不想做呢?別說「Yes, I mind.」那樣太直接了。試試「Sorry, I’d rather not.」或「Sorry, I can’t right now.」先說 Sorry 會柔和很多。
J
Later in the story, Eric needs the restroom. And Eric says, “Can I ask you something too? Would you mind to let me out? I need the restroom.” Rachel says, “Not at all.” Then she adds a tip.故事後來,Eric 要去洗手間。Eric 說:「Can I ask you something too? Would you mind to let me out? I need the restroom.」Rachel 說:「Not at all.」然後她又補了一個小提醒。
M
And Rachel says, “Little tip: would you mind letting me out. No to, just the ing form.” So after “mind,” use the ing word. Would you mind closing it? Would you mind helping me? Would you mind speaking slower?然後 Rachel 說:「Little tip: would you mind letting me out. No to, just the ing form.」所以 mind 後面要接 ing 的字。Would you mind closing it? Would you mind helping me? Would you mind speaking slower?
J
Eric says, “Would you mind letting me out. Got it! Thanks for the free English lesson.” Now what if you want to ask permission? Use “Would you mind if I sit here?” Or the casual one, “Mind if I join you?”Eric 說:「Would you mind letting me out. Got it! Thanks for the free English lesson.」那如果你是要問可不可以呢?用「Would you mind if I sit here?」或隨性一點的「Mind if I join you?」
M
I messed this up once. A woman on a train asked, “Would you mind if I sit here?” and I said, “Yes, please!” She froze. I laughed and said, “I mean, not at all!” Now I say, “Go ahead.” It’s easy.我也搞砸過一次。有位女士在火車上問:「Would you mind if I sit here?」我回:「Yes, please!」她僵住了。我笑著說:「I mean, not at all!」現在我會說「Go ahead.」很簡單。
J
Good fix. Remember the “if,” though. Don’t say, “Would you mind I sit here?” That one is missing a word. Say, “Would you mind if I sit here?” Then the answer can be “Go ahead” or “Not at all.”改得好。不過別忘了 if。不要說「Would you mind I sit here?」那句少了一個字。要說「Would you mind if I sit here?」然後答案可以是「Go ahead」或「Not at all.」
M
Now the politeness ladder. Step one is “Can you pass the salt?” That’s casual, great for friends. Step two is “Could you pass the salt?” That’s more polite. Step three is “Would you mind passing the salt?” That’s the extra polite one.現在來看禮貌的階梯。第一階是「Can you pass the salt?」這句很隨性,跟朋友講很適合。第二階是「Could you pass the salt?」比較客氣。第三階是「Would you mind passing the salt?」更客氣、更有禮貌。
J
So who gets which one? Friends get “Can you.” Most people get “Could you.” And when you want to sound extra polite, like with an older person or a client, use “Would you mind.” If you’re not sure, start with “Could you.” You won’t go wrong.那誰適合哪一句?朋友用「Can you」。一般人用「Could you」。想特別客氣的時候,像是對長輩或客戶,就用「Would you mind」。如果不確定,就從「Could you」開始,不會錯。
M
Let’s try a mini quiz. Someone says, “Would you mind moving your bag?” You’re happy to do it. What do you say? Right, “No, not at all.” Or “Sure.” Just don’t say “Yes.”來個小測驗。有人說:「Would you mind moving your bag?」你很樂意移開。你要怎麼說?沒錯,「No, not at all.」或「Sure.」只要別說 Yes。
J
Another one. Your boss asks, “Would you mind staying late today?” But you have plans. You can say, “Sorry, I can’t tonight. I already have plans.” Short, kind, and clear.再一題。老闆問:「Would you mind staying late today?」但你今天有事。你可以說「Sorry, I can’t tonight. I already have plans.」簡短、客氣又清楚。
M
So let’s sum it up. Say yes with “Not at all.” Say no with “Sorry, I’d rather not.” Ask a favor with “Would you mind” plus ing. Ask permission with “if I.” That’s the whole toolbox.我們來總結。想答應就說「Not at all.」想拒絕就說「Sorry, I’d rather not.」要拜託人就用「Would you mind」加 ing。要問可不可以就用「if I」。這樣就夠你用了。
J
Great. Now for the fun part. Listen to Eric and Rachel’s conversation one more time. This time, hear what Eric says, and what Rachel notices. You’ll catch much more than the first time.太好了。接下來是好玩的部分。再聽一次 Eric 和 Rachel 的對話。這次仔細聽 Eric 說了什麼,還有 Rachel 注意到什麼。你會比第一次聽到更多。
M
Okay, sit back and relax. You already know the rules, so you can follow every word. Nothing new, just a fresh listen. Just enjoy the flight. Here’s the whole thing.好,放輕鬆。規則你都知道了,所以每個字都跟得上。沒有新東西,就是重新聽一遍。好好享受這趟飛行吧。完整對話來了。
🔁 [DIALOGUE REPLAY] 重播情境對話
J
See? The second time, Eric still says “Yes, of course!” and “mind to let me out.” Now you can hear both mistakes right away, and you know exactly how to fix them.看吧?第二次聽,Eric 還是說「Yes, of course!」和「mind to let me out」。現在你一聽就知道這兩個錯,也知道該怎麼改。
M
Tell us in the comments: when did someone ask you “Would you mind” and you weren’t sure what to say? Write your answer in English, and we’ll help. And follow MJ English for more.在留言告訴我們:什麼時候有人問你「Would you mind」,而你不知道怎麼回?用英文寫下你的答案,我們幫你看看。也記得追蹤 MJ English 看更多內容。
J
Thanks for hanging out with us today!謝謝你今天陪我們聊天!
M
Have a lovely week, and see you soon!祝你這週過得愉快,我們很快再見!

延伸學習 Keep Going

客氣拜託、禮貌拒絕,這幾集一起看。

你被問過 Would you mind 嗎?當時你怎麼回?用英文留言一句你會怎麼答應,我們幫你看看!

留言你最常不知道怎麼回的英文問句,我們排進之後的節目。

追蹤 MJ英語 podcast,下次見。

標題和URL已復制